Grey Nike running shoes, size 9, lost near Safeway

I'm missing my grey Nike running shoes, size 9. They're a lightly used pair with a neon lime-green heel tab and a small blue scuff on the left toe. I last wore them yesterday around 3pm and think I might have left them near the Safeway on Colusa Highway in Marysville, Yuba-Sutter, after grabbing a snack. The left shoe has a tiny puncture near the sole, and one lace is frayed. They're pretty important to me—they were a gift from my sister, and I'd be beyond grateful to get them back.